Posts

How Geertz Helped to Socialize Ryle

Image
I have not uploaded a post for couple of months so I decided to write a short post about what currently occupies me. My blog is not dead, not yet! First of all, I work on a paper for the annual conference of AntropoWeb which will be held in Pilsen from 17 to 19 October this year. My paper will be about my experience with studying anthropology at the Durham University. To be honest the word “work” is far from being true - I have not started yet. But I will start... soon. Do not worry if you are unable to take part, the subsequent article will be in English. Secondly, I work on a paper about the famous anthropologist, all-star intellectual who helped a vast public make sense of the human condition (in Robert Darnton’s words), Clifford Geertz. I have been engaged with Geertz’s theory since wrote my first really academic article. In that article I argued that Geertz’s theory of religion contributes little to our understanding of religion and that very similar framework for studyi...

Is Eco the Czech Derrida?

Image
In 1992 the University of Cambridge decided to award Jacques Derrida, the famous French philosopher, a honorary degree. A letter of protest followed. It was written by Barry Smith then editor of the journal Monist  and it was signed by philosophers from all around the world. Among those who signed the letter were Willard van Orman Quine and Wolfgang Röd. The letter and a subsequent discussion epitomize one of the key issues in the twentieth century philosophy - a rift between analytic and continental philosophy. After all the University of Cambridge decided to award Derrida the degree. But even if Derrida had not received the degree, the debate can be understood as a stimulating and interesting lesson in philosophy. It is not without interest that John R. Searle, a longstanding opponent of Derrida (e.g. their disagreement over the interpretation of Austin’s speech acts or over the importance of writer’s intentions), did not sign the letter of protest. Something seemingly ...

Rollo May: The Cry for Myth

Image
I have just recently finished reading of another book about my favorite topic - mythology. This time it was a book by an American existentialist psychologist Rollo May (1909-1994) called The Cry for Myth  and which was published in 1991. Since I do not know much about psychology, I was not sure if I would be able to understand the book. But I must admit that the book turned out to be a big surprise. The book is divided into two major parts. The first part is theoretical. In it, May presents some ideas about the nature of myth and mythology. I did not enjoy this part much because it is based on a very eclectic theoretical approach. He quotes two different Malinowski’s ideas about the nature of myth - once, myth serves deep moral cravings, for the second time, it enforces morality. May then quotes Jung and says that myths express the deep collective unconscious and immediately after this he quotes Lévi-Strauss for whom “the myth describes lived experience”. And finally Ma...

G. R. R. Martin: The defense of fantasy in the ironic mode

Image
It has been two weeks since the first episode of the third season of TV series Game of Thrones  was aired. I became interested in GoT  in 2011 during the first season. Since the time, I have seen the complete first season, some episodes from the second and the first two episodes of the third. Since I prefer reading to watching, I was dragged to George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire  on which the ongoing series is based. As I am not a native speaker of English and I have other work to do, I have been able to read the first two volumes only - Game of Thrones  and A Clash of Kings . Many people who like fantasy say that they like the George R. R. Martin’s saga, because it is an unusual piece of fantasy. The book is rich of many different and interesting characters, and the narrative does not seem to fit the cut-and-dried struggle of the good against the evil, the cornerstone of any classic fantastic story which we know from the works of J. R. R. Tolki...

Ivan Strenski and theories of myth

Image
Couple of weeks ago I accidentally ran into one book in the Bill Bryson library. I was looking for some anthropological books about myth and religion when I spotted a spine with the title saying: Four Theories of Myth in the Twentieth-Century History . I do not usually borrow books at random from a library, but I made an exception for this one, because after I skimmed through it, I decided that it was worth reading. The book was written by an American scholar Ivan Strenski and published in 1987. I have never heard of Mr. Strenski before, however, his book turned out to be a really good one. The book is about four major thinkers on the field of myth in the twentieth century: Neo-Kantian philosopher Ernst Cassirer, historian of religion Mircea Eliade, and two famous anthropologists - Bronislaw Malinowski and Claude Lévi-Strauss. Ivan Strenski gives his readers some basic ideas about all four theories, and he also places them in their historical context. For example, Strenski t...

Kanón antisociologa

Image
Nejednou jsem (nejen) na internetu narazil na názor, že sociologie je pavěda nebo nesmysl (například nedávno zrušený blog Marty Krausové na idnes.cz). Nevím, kde někteří lidé berou tu jistotu, která je k takovým soudům opravňuje. Nemyslím si, že pouze sociální vědci jsou oprávněni kritizovat sociální vědy. Občas by ale neškodilo, kdyby si účastníci křížového tažení proti sociologii z řad nesociologů přečetli nějaké klasické nebo současné sociologické dílo, aby pochopili, co vlastně kritizují. Představují kanóny antisociologů těžký kalibr? Názor, že sociologie je pavěda, je jedním z nejhloupějších názorů vůbec. Mohlo by se zdát, že se jedná o české specifikum, neboť za komunismu byla sociologie považována za buržoazní pavědu. Takové vysvětlení však neobstojí vzhledem ke skutečnosti, že ani za hranicemi to neměla sociologie vždy jednoduché. Jako důkaz dobře poslouží článek amerického sociologa Roberta Kinga Mertona Kánon antisociologa . Z něj lze vyčíst, že kritika sociologie ja...

Okurková sezóna

Image
A je to tady, okurková sezóna se nám rozjela v plné síle. Abych nezůstal pozadu za českými médii, rozhodnul jsem se vylepšit vzhled blogu Modus Vivendi . Stále ještě bojuji s tím, jak udělat hezky vypadající citace (pravda je taková, že vůbec nevím, jak se to dělá; asi po desátém neúspěšném pokusu o naprogramování css a po opakovaném spadnutí wi-fi jsem dostal chuť ničit vše kolem sebe), ale podstatné změny už jsou hotové. Ti bystřejší si jistě všimli, že hlavní změnou je vzhled blogu. Světlejší koncept působí přívětivějším dojmem, lépe se čte a nekontrastuje tolik s barevností obrázků. Kromě celkového konceptu jsem na konec každého příspěvku přidal i další dvě možnosti hodnocení. Vedle dosavadních možností vtipné , zajímavé a skvělé nově objevíte i možnosti nudné a hloupé . Protože jsem vás všecky prokouknul, tak jsem vynechal možnosti odpad  a škoda slov (protože byste pak soutěžili v tom, která z těchto možností získá větší počet hlasů). K rozšíření nabídky mě ved...